Cover version of the month #117
Big Star cover The Velvet Underground
The Velvet Underground and Big Star are two majestical, mythical and magical bands that have influenced (and have been consistently highlighted by) Scottish bands like Orange Juice and Teenage Fanclub through to bands bursting on to the scene at present.
Art-rock NYC cool, melodic vulnerability, quintessential guitar power pop and vocal harmonies. You could easily argue that the two bands stand as the ultimate patron saints to the Glasgow independent guitar pop scene. Throw in Love, The Byrds, punk bands like Buzzcocks, The Clash and Subway Sect and that's the bones of your top 10.
One song that links both of these legendary bands is Femme Fatale, written by Lou Reed and inspired by a throwaway Andy Warhol comment about Factory 'it-girl' Edie Sedgwick. New info for me - I always thought it was about (and for) Nico!
"Oh, don't you think she's a Femme Fatale, Lou?"
The Velvets recorded the song in 1966 and it was released as the b-side to Sunday Morning in December of that year and then as the third track on their debut album, the mind blowing The Velvet Underground & Nico in March 1967. It's an album that everyone with a vested interest in the history of guitar music seems to be magnetically drawn to as a teenager.
It's well documented that the album was a flop, entering the charts at number 199 upon release and then leaving the month afterwards. Check this excellent feature article by Scottish writer Grant McPhee for Into Creative.
McPhee takes a deep dive into the myth of The Velvet Underground and Nico, particularly around the sales figures, stemming from a famous quote by Brian Eno about the album only selling 30,000 copies in its first five years.
... everyone who bought one of those 30,000 copies started a band. Brian Eno
Enjoy Grant's blog. But back to Femme Fatale. Listening again, I can't help but wonder who (if anyone) Nico was thinking of whilst singing the song. Edie? Or herself?
Here she comes
You'd better watch your step
She's going to break your heart in two
It's true
The Velvets recording is icy cool. Nico’s vocals are famously flat, off-key and the way she pronounces clown as clun at the end of the second verse is quite funny. Funny, but ridiculously cool!
She'll build you up just to put you down
What a clown
Almost 60-years on and The Velvet Underground remain a blueprint for independent guitar music. Femme Fatale is a prime example why. Short (2-minutes 39 seconds), seemingly simple, impossibly cool and utterly beautiful. Pop music can be both a hook and a heartbreak simultaneously.
Lou Reed's NYC drawl in response to Nico's rise for the chorus is sublime.
Cause everybody knows, (She's a femme fatale)
The things she does to me, (She's a femme fatale)
She's just a little tease, (She's a femme fatale)
The closing two lines of the chorus are left to Nico, over the chiming guitar riff. They are, for me, the two coolest lines of the song, sung as if Nico is in admiration of the girl she is singing of.
See the way she walks
Hear the way she talks
In the next verses, Nico (using Lou's words of course) is clearer about her warning. The guy is merely number thirty-seven in her book. She's from the street, so already has all the guys beat and is going to play you for a fool.
Alex Chilton recorded his version for the legendary Third/Sister Lovers album sessions. The Big Star version is stripped back and fragile. Chilton sounds like he is singing from the experience of having his heart broken by the femme fatale, warning others, yet still infatuated.
Big Star are in no rush here, everything is slow, the intro longer, it all feels darker, as if Chilton is barely holding it together. It's beautiful.
Others have covered this gem of a song too. Among them - I've just found the Duran Duran version ... and ... I'm not a fan! Teenage Fanclub covered it with tender care on the b-side of Ain't That Enough. And Fatale, who I have written about a number of times over the last 6-months or so, took their name from the song and recorded it as their first demo. The way the crowd sing-a-long with Lou's she's a femme fatale line at the Fatale gigs is incredible - like they are breathing new life into the song and turning it into an anthem.
The Velvet Underground & Nico original and the Big Star cover of Femme Fatale are added to my Everything Flows Cool Cover Versions playlist on Spotify which also features all of the songs listed below. Search for the title or CLICK HERE
Previous covers of the month blogs
40. Jumpin' Jack Flash
44. Witchi Tai To
45. Our Lips Are Sealed
46. Sunshine Of Your Love
47. Here Comes The Sun
48. I Think We're Alone Now
49. Don't Let Me Down
50. It's Oh So Quiet
51. Alcoholiday
52. Summer Holiday
53. Who Do You Think You Are?
54. Head On
55. Nothing Compares 2 U
